Live SoMa | Jun 24, 2010 | Comments 0
When all is said and done, the San Francisco Young Democrats District 6 Candidate Forum went off without a hitch. In fact, I’m pretty sure the most heated person at the Forum had to be the Fire Marshall as crowds of local residents and supporters overflowed the community room at the South Beach Yacht Club.
Special thanks to the planners who decided to host the event in a room that was completely back lit. It was probably fine for some of the ‘professional photographers,’ but with my local community (read: small time) budget, it almost rendered my camera completely useless.
So what did we learn at last nights forum? For starters, the ‘let’s pick on the new kid’ strategy implemented by more than 50% of participating candidates pretty much backfired. During the candidate vs. candidate round, everyone (save for Theresa and Deborah, who both exchanged blows) threw a question at Jane Kim. I was even waiting for Kim to drill herself on how ‘new and inexperienced’ she is within the District.
I couldn’t tell if it was an ‘easy’ attempt to derail Kim’s campaign before it even begins, or a way of avoiding the heavyweight candidates on the right side of the panel. Or maybe it was a conscious choice from all candidates to ignore that side of the room and all of their hot air. Either way, I was disappointed by this tactic. Jane held her own (with assistance from her note pad) and we learned nothing from any of the other candidates; hence it was a small waste of an hour of time that could have been better spent fixing Muni.
I don’t pretend to be a Political Savant of any sort. However, as a citizen and resident of the South of Market Neighborhood, here is my take on each of the candidates as I witnessed them yesterday:
I realize that Deborah is the perceived front runner. I’m not sure what God-like figure is behind her curtain, but I certainly would appreciate an honest answer to just one question.
Every time she speaks, it sounds rehearsed and ‘voter-friendly’. The other quality her answers all seem to share is that they never contain an answer to the question that is asked.
Next time, you may want to consider bringing a smaller entourage with you as the community rooms in which these events are held are pretty small. It would be better if you allowed actual voters to have a spot, rather than a room full of Walker Blowhards.
.
Similar to Ms. Walker, Theresa is also a perceived front-runner. Again, that just says to me that there’s someone important pulling the strings behind the scenes because- as a community member in District 6- I have yet to see her do much of anything.
She at least had an answer to Deborah Walker’s question about corruption in the SFPD while Sparks served on the Police Commission, even if that answer was ‘my hands were tied.’
.
.
As the forum moderator, Melissa Griffin, mentioned, how does the oldest candidate in the race have the coolest website? He’s also the only candidate as of yet who has been actively releasing online videos about his platform.
He held his own against the big wigs, primarily because he’s a very active community advocate in SOMA, and has been active for decades. He also lacks the ‘political polish’ of Walker and Sparks, but that can be seen as either good or bad. Good because he seems ‘real’, bad because ‘real’ is usually tough to translate into votes.
.
This was my first experience with Anna Conda. Quite honestly, I considered her candidacy a joke, much like Gary Coleman for Governor in 2003. She held her own though, coming off as more informed and honest about the issues she was asked to speak on.
My one problem with her comment on night club trash removal was that this City is cash-strapped, so adding programs to the district that won’t generate clear revenue is probably not a great idea. Although it would be nice to get rid of night club trash in ways other than dumping it into the Bay.
.
One of the victims of the Jane Kim Show had to be James Keys. I must say that his campaign photos are much more commanding than his forum presence.
This was my first experience with Mr. Keys as well, and I was slightly expecting more of a presence from him. He seemed kind and friendly, but in a cage full of hungry lions, that gets you nowhere.
.
.
.
.
.
Jane reminds me of a high school math teacher, who was so nice that nobody wanted to disrupt her class. In the political arena, niceness (and youth) apparently places a target on your forehead.
Aside from constantly referring to her note pad and the one preface of “I haven’t yet read that…”, I felt that she maintained her composure despite the fact that the panel spent most of the hour watching her jump through hoops.
.
.
I like Matt Drake. He’s a good guy. Unfortunately, the forum didn’t give him much to talk about, so I have no idea what his platform is. His only memorable moment in the forum was a softball audience question that asked him his stance on the Folsom Street Festival, as well as if he plans to attend and what he’ll wear. His answer? He supports the festival and feels it’s good for the community even though he doesn’t always attend. He added that when he does go, he’ll likely wear more clothing than most of the other participants. I would have said that I would wear much less clothing than a stuffy suit instead.
Lastly, I would like to send some serious props to Melissa Griffin for doing a fantastic job as Forum Moderator. She kept the tone light and fun, even when some of the candidates tried to get more serious. I also respect anyone who’ll go into a room full of political candidates and crack some jokes about them, regardless of how lightly toned they were.
And one more thanks to our friends over at VidSF for providing the Live stream here on LiveSOMA. They also create other, local, non-political content, so check them out.
I’ve been chatting with them about getting an ‘on demand’ version of the forum that you can reference in the future. More to come on that…
—————————————————
It is our goal at LiveSOMA.com to help build a stronger community by sharing local issues and ideas in an open forum. We are not endorsing any single candidate as we have invited each to contribute. It is at their sole discretion as to whether they contribute or not.
Related posts:
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
Filed Under: Around the Neighborhood • Featured • Local Events • The Community